State plainly how long they have, what condition it must be in, who pays return postage, and how long a refund takes. A clear policy raises conversion because uncertainty is what stops people ordering.

Two audiences, one page

A returns policy is read by two kinds of person, and most are written for only one.

The first is somebody deciding whether to order, checking what happens if it is wrong. They are the larger group by a wide margin.

The second is somebody who already wants to return something.

Written defensively, the page serves neither. It reassures nobody and it makes the return process feel adversarial before it has even started.

Why clarity increases sales

Buying something you cannot handle first involves accepting a risk.

A clear, generous-sounding returns position removes most of that risk, which removes the reason to hesitate.

This is why the shops with the most straightforward returns are frequently the ones with the highest conversion. The policy is not a cost centre; it is part of what makes ordering feel safe.

The counter-intuitive part is that clearer policies do not necessarily produce more returns. They produce more orders, and the return rate stays roughly where it was.

The four questions to answer

  1. How long do I have? A number of days, from a stated starting point.
  2. What condition must it be in? Unused, original packaging, or something looser.
  3. Who pays the postage back? The question people most want answered and the one most often buried.
  4. How long until I get my money? From when you receive it, not from when they post it.

Answer those four in the very first paragraph, in plain numbers, and the page has done its main job before anybody needs to read any further.

A worked example

An online homeware shop whose returns page ran to about six hundred words of conditions, exceptions and disclaimers.

It had been adapted from a template and nobody had read it since.

They replaced the opening with four lines: thirty days from delivery, unused and in original packaging, you pay return postage unless the item is faulty, refund within five working days of it arriving back.

The remaining conditions stayed, below, for anybody who needed them.

Conversion rose by a few percent, which on their volume was meaningful. The return rate was unchanged.

What they had not expected was the drop in emails: the page had previously generated questions because nobody could extract the answer from it.

Who pays return postage

The decision with the largest effect on both conversion and cost.

Free returns increase orders noticeably and cost real money on every return.

Customer-paid returns cost you nothing and deter some orders, particularly for anything where size or fit is uncertain.

The middle position most small shops land on: the customer pays unless the item is faulty or wrongly sent, which is both reasonable and what the law requires anyway.

Whatever you choose, state it plainly. The frustration is not paying postage; it is discovering you have to after deciding to return something.

The legal floor

Worth knowing, because policy sits on top of it.

Faulty goods, goods not as described, and goods that do not do what was claimed are covered by consumer protection law regardless of what your policy says.

A policy cannot remove those rights, and a policy that appears to try reads badly to a customer and does not help you.

Your policy governs the discretionary part: change-of-mind returns, which you are generally not obliged to accept and which most shops accept anyway because it sells more.

The provinces differ in detail, and the general shape is consistent enough to write a policy that works nationally. If you sell into the United States, their rules differ again and are worth checking separately.

The counter-case

Where a restrictive policy is correct.

Perishable goods, custom-made items, and anything hygiene-related where resale is impossible. Those exceptions are standard and customers accept them readily when they are stated clearly before purchase.

Very low-margin items where a return costs more than the profit on the sale.

And handmade or one-off pieces where the customer has seen photographs of the specific item rather than a product type.

In all of those the answer is to state the exception prominently before purchase, not to bury it in a policy nobody reads until afterwards.

Making the process work

The policy is a promise; the process is whether it is kept.

Say exactly what to do: contact first or send it back, which address, what to include.

Acknowledge a return when it arrives rather than only when the refund is processed, because the gap between posting something and hearing anything is where anxiety lives.

And refund promptly. A slow refund produces more ill will than the original problem did, because by then the customer has nothing and is out of pocket.

Refund to the original payment method rather than offering credit as a default. Store credit as an option is fine; store credit instead of a refund is what generates complaints and occasionally a dispute with your payment provider.

What returns tell you

Worth reading rather than only processing, because they are the most honest feedback you get.

Every return has a reason, and the reasons cluster. Size wrong points at photography or a missing measurement. Not as described points at the description or the colour in the images. Faulty points at the supplier or the packaging.

A shop returning one product disproportionately has a page problem rather than a product problem, and the page is cheaper to fix.

Record the stated reason on every return, even informally. After thirty of them the pattern is obvious and it usually names one or two products.

That is the same material that improves the descriptions and the photographs, arriving free and unprompted.

Where the page belongs

Linked from the product page, the basket, the checkout and the footer.

The product page matters most, because that is where the hesitation actually occurs. A single line saying thirty day returns, linked through to the detail, does the work at the exact moment it is needed.

Hiding it in the footer alone means the reassurance arrives only for the people who went looking, which is a small minority of those it would otherwise have persuaded to order.

The same reasoning applies to delivery expectations, covered in what your delivery estimate is promising.

Frequently asked questions

Who reads a returns policy?

Mostly people deciding whether to order, checking what happens if it is wrong. That group is far larger than people actually returning something.

Does a clear policy increase returns?

Generally not. It increases orders while the return rate stays roughly where it was, because uncertainty is what was stopping people.

What four questions must it answer?

How long they have, what condition it must be in, who pays return postage, and how long a refund takes from when you receive it.

Who should pay return postage?

Most small shops land on the customer paying unless the item is faulty or wrongly sent, which is reasonable and what the law requires anyway.

Can a policy override consumer law?

No. Faulty goods, goods not as described, and goods that do not do what was claimed are covered regardless of what your policy says.

Where should the policy be linked?

The product page above all, because that is where hesitation happens. Footer-only means the reassurance reaches only those who went looking.

West Coast Media Solutions Inc. provides web design, web development, hosting, digital marketing, and business consulting to organisations across Canada, drawing on more than twenty-five years in the field.

Returns page adapted from a template years ago?

Four plain sentences at the top usually raises conversion and reduces the emails asking what it means.

Start a Conversation