Change a logo only for a reason customers would notice, price every sign, vehicle, uniform and listing first, and keep what people already recognise. Then change the sign and online profiles together, and let the rest follow.

A camera people turned out to miss

Instagram changed its app icon yesterday. The brown, old-fashioned camera is gone, and in its place is a simple outline of a camera on a bright gradient of purple, pink and orange.

The app itself went black and white, so that the photographs supply the colour.

The reaction was quick and mostly unhappy. People who had never given the old icon a thought found they were attached to it, and said so.

A company that size can absorb the noise. For a small business, the same attachment shows up at the counter, and the bill for a new logo arrives on signs, vans and aprons.

Why people get attached to a mark

Customers rarely look at a logo closely. They recognise it from a distance, by shape and colour, the way you spot a friend's car in a parking lot.

That recognition is built over years of passing the sign, holding the cup and seeing the icon on a phone. A new logo starts it again from nothing.

Which is why the loudest objections usually come from the most loyal customers. Their complaint is rarely about the design itself. What they notice is that something familiar has gone.

What a new logo actually costs

The third is the one owners forget to count. Embroidery is priced per piece, so replacing every shirt at once costs far more than replacing them as they wear out.

Reasons that hold up

Some reasons for a new logo are about customers and some are about the owner. Only the first kind justify the cost.

A logo that cannot be read at small sizes is a real problem when so many first impressions happen on a phone: a profile picture, a map pin, a browser tab.

A name change, a merger or a move into different work can leave the old mark describing a business that no longer exists. A logo resembling a competitor's confuses people every week.

Being tired of it is not on the list. The owner sees the logo every day; customers see it in passing.

Refresh before you replace

Most small business logos do not need replacing. They need redrawing.

A designer can keep the colour, shape and feel customers recognise while tidying the lettering, simplifying the detail and adding a version that works at thumbnail size.

Instagram's new icon keeps the idea of a camera and drops the detail, which at least reads more clearly at the size of an icon.

A refresh costs much the same to roll out as a replacement, but it keeps the recognition you have already paid for.

A worked example

A pancake house on a commercial strip has used the same logo since it opened in the 1980s: its name in round red letters over a stack of pancakes with a pat of butter on top.

New owners took over last year and asked for a modern look. The first proposal was a slim grey wordmark with no pancakes, and when staff showed it to a few regulars, the reaction was much like Instagram's.

The mechanism was recognition. Regulars knew the place by the red lettering and the stack, glimpsed from a passing car, and the new mark threw away both.

The designer redrew the original instead: the same red, the stack simplified to three clean shapes, the lettering tidied, and a square version of the stack alone for profile pictures and the browser tab.

The sign was repainted the same week the website, Facebook page and Google listing changed, so people searching and people driving past saw the same thing.

Menus switched at the next reprint, aprons as they wore out, and the old mugs stayed.

Change what customers compare together

Most confusion in a logo change comes from mismatch: one logo on the listing, another over the door, and a customer wondering whether this is the right place.

For a shop or restaurant, the sign and the online profiles are what customers compare most, so change them close together, ideally in the same week.

Items customers never see side by side can wait. Nobody holds a menu up against the van.

Tell people it is the same business

A new logo can look like new owners, a new menu, or a closure and reopening. Regulars who are not told will guess.

A short note covers it: same people, same food or service, new look, on the website, the Facebook page, the newsletter and a card by the till.

If the business really has changed hands, say so plainly. The note is there to prevent the wrong conclusion, not to disguise a change.

The small sizes online

Online, a logo has to work at sizes it was never drawn for. The site icon in a browser tab is a few pixels across, and Instagram crops profile pictures into a small circle.

In WordPress, themes that support it let you set the logo and the site icon in the Customizer, so the website part of the switch is quick once the files exist.

Ask the designer for the full set first: the main logo, a square version, a one-colour version and the small icon.

The counter-case

Sometimes a clean break is right. A business that has outgrown its name, or whose mark is tied to work it no longer does, may do better with a new logo.

A very new business, with a year of history and few signs, can change at little cost and with little attachment to lose.

And a logo assembled from a font and a piece of clip art may have nothing worth keeping.

For most established small businesses, though, the advice stands: count the cost, refresh rather than replace, and change what customers compare at the same time.

Before you commit

  1. Write down the reason for the change.
  2. List every sign, vehicle and uniform.
  3. Get prices before approving a design.
  4. Ask for a refresh before a replacement.
  5. Test the mark at thumbnail size.
  6. Change the sign and profiles together.
  7. Tell regulars it is the same business.

Step three is the one that changes decisions. A design approved before anyone has priced the signs and the van tends to be rolled out halfway, leaving two logos in use for years.

Where the logo should lead once it is on the website is covered in the logo that does not go home.

Frequently asked questions

What did Instagram change this week?

It replaced the brown, old-fashioned camera icon with a simple camera outline on a bright gradient, and redesigned the app itself in black and white.

Why do customers react badly to new logos?

Because they recognise a logo by shape and colour, built up over years. A new mark removes something familiar, and loyal customers notice first.

What does a logo change really cost?

Signs, vehicle lettering, embroidered uniforms, printed stock, website work and every listing. Signs and vehicles are usually the largest items; uniforms are the most often forgotten.

When is a new logo worth it?

When the old one cannot be read at small sizes, describes a business that has changed, or resembles a competitor's. Being tired of it is not a reason.

Should I refresh or replace my logo?

Usually refresh. A designer can keep the colour and shape customers recognise while simplifying the detail, which keeps the recognition you have already built.

How do I avoid confusing customers?

Change the sign and the online profiles in the same week, tell regulars it is the same business, and let items nobody compares wear out on schedule.

West Coast Media Solutions Inc. provides web design, web development, hosting, digital marketing, and business consulting to organisations across Canada, drawing on more than twenty-five years in the field.

Thinking about a new logo?

Send us the current one and a list of where it appears. We will suggest what to keep and what the change will cost.

Start a Conversation