Conversion rate is the share of visitors who take the action you wanted, which for a service business means enquiring by phone or form. It matters more than traffic because improving it raises the return on every visitor you already have, including the ones you are paying for.
The arithmetic
Enquiries divided by visitors, as a percentage. Two hundred visitors and six enquiries is three percent.
The reason it matters more than traffic is compounding. Getting more visitors costs money or months. Improving the rate is usually a one-time change that then applies to every visitor afterwards, including the ones you were already getting for nothing.
A business at two percent that reaches four has doubled its enquiries with no additional traffic and no additional advertising. That is the whole argument, and it is why fixing conversion before buying visitors is nearly always the right order.
What counts as a conversion
This is where the number goes wrong for most small businesses, because the obvious definition misses most of what happens.
- A form submission, confirmed as delivered rather than merely submitted.
- A tap on your phone number, which is the majority of enquiries for many trades and is invisible unless it is deliberately recorded.
- A click on your email address.
- A completed booking, where you take them.
Counting only form submissions is the standard error. A trades business where most people phone will calculate a rate of under one percent, conclude the website is failing, and rebuild something that was working. The number was wrong, not the site.
What a good rate looks like
Published benchmarks are close to useless here, because the figure depends entirely on who is arriving.
| Traffic type | What to expect |
|---|---|
| Someone searching your business name | High. They already decided; they are looking for the number |
| Someone searching an urgent local service | Good. Ready to act, comparing two or three options |
| Someone searching a general question | Low, and appropriately so. They are researching, not hiring |
| Someone arriving from social | Usually low. They were not looking for you at all |
A site at eight percent might be doing badly if all its traffic is people searching its own name. A site at one and a half percent might be doing well if most arrivals are early-stage research. The overall figure is a blend, which is why the useful comparison is against your own previous months rather than against anyone else.
Where the losses usually are
Mobile against desktop
The first split worth running, and it finds more problems than any other. A site converting at six percent on desktop and one on mobile has a mechanical fault: a form that is awkward on a phone, an untappable number, or a page that is slow on a mobile connection.
Pages with no way to act
A service page that ends with a link to the contact page is asking someone to hold their interest across a page load. Every service page should carry the number and a short form.
Questions the page does not answer
Whether you cover their area. Whether you can come soon. Roughly what it costs. Leaving these open sends people back to the results page to find someone who answered them.
A form that asks too much
Ten fields to request a quote reads as a screening exercise. Four or five is usually the whole requirement, and the rest can be established on the call.
Enquiries that arrive and go nowhere
Not strictly a conversion problem and it is the largest loss in many businesses. A form that silently fails to deliver, or a callback that takes two days, undoes everything the site did.
The first thing to check
Before analysing anything, submit your own form from a phone on mobile data and confirm the message arrives, including checking the junk folder of the receiving address. Then tap your own phone number from your own site and confirm it dials the right number.
Both take two minutes. Both fail more often than anyone expects, and both fail silently, which means a business can lose months of enquiries without a single symptom appearing anywhere.
Improving it, in order
- Confirm enquiries can be made and received. Everything else is theoretical until this is verified.
- Fix the mobile experience, since that is where most visitors and most problems are.
- Put a way to act on every service page.
- Answer the three questions: area, availability, and rough cost.
- Shorten the form.
- Speed up the response, because an enquiry answered within the hour behaves very differently from one answered tomorrow.
The number to hold onto
Conversion rate is a diagnostic. The number that matters to the business is enquiries, and specifically enquiries you wanted.
Twenty enquiries for work you do not want is not a better month than eight for work you do. Tracking the rate is how you find what is broken. Tracking the count and the quality is how you know whether the year is going well, and those are different jobs done with different numbers.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good website conversion rate?
It depends entirely on who is arriving. Someone searching your business name converts far better than someone reading a general guide, so the useful comparison is against your own previous months rather than a published benchmark.
What should count as a conversion?
Form submissions confirmed as delivered, taps on your phone number, clicks on your email address, and completed bookings. Counting only form submissions badly understates a business where most people phone.
Why is my mobile conversion rate so much lower?
Usually something mechanical: a form that is awkward on a phone, a number that is not set up as a tappable link, or a page that is slow over a mobile connection.
Should I improve conversion or get more traffic first?
Conversion, in almost every case. It is usually a one-time change that then raises the return on every visitor you already have, including the ones you are paying for.
What is the fastest conversion check I can run?
Submit your own form from a phone on mobile data and confirm it arrives, checking the junk folder too. Then tap your own number and confirm it dials correctly. Both fail more often than expected and both fail silently.
Is conversion rate the number I should report on?
Use it to find what is broken, and judge the business on enquiries and their quality. Twenty enquiries for work you do not want is not a better month than eight for work you do.
West Coast Media Solutions Inc. provides web design, web development, hosting, digital marketing, and business consulting to organisations across Canada, drawing on more than twenty-five years in the field.
Getting visitors but not enquiries?
We find where the loss is concentrated, starting with whether your form and phone number actually work, then fix the pages costing you the most.
Start a Conversation