Most directories generate entries from public data without asking, so a business is listed in places it never chose. The response depends on the entry: claim and correct the ones customers use, ignore the ones nobody visits, and understand what the lead-selling ones are actually doing.

Where they come from

Rarely from anyone at your business.

Directories compile entries from public records, aggregated business data, and each other. That means a business is listed in dozens of places it never registered with, frequently with details taken from a source that is now out of date.

The details in those entries are whatever the source held when it was scraped, which is why an old phone number can persist on sites you have never visited for years.

The categories, which need different responses

Entries customers actually use

The map platforms, the major review sites, and anything that appears when somebody searches your name.

These matter. Claim them, correct the details, and keep them accurate. Even where you did not create them, they are now part of how you appear.

Low-traffic directories

The long tail of aggregated listing sites nobody visits directly. Individually irrelevant.

Worth correcting only where the details are wrong in a way that matters, particularly the phone number, since consistency across sources affects local search and a wrong number occasionally gets called.

Lead-selling platforms

Sites that list your business, then sell the enquiry to whoever pays. Your listing exists to make the directory look comprehensive; the enquiry goes to a paying member.

This is worth understanding rather than resenting. The listing is bait, and unless you pay, it produces nothing for you while helping the platform rank for your trade.

Entries with wrong or damaging information

A closed status on a business that is open, a wrong category, a merged entry mixing you with another business, or a rating from reviews that are not yours.

These need attention regardless of the site's traffic, because a closed status in particular can propagate.

Finding them

Three searches cover most of it.

Your business name in quotation marks. Your current phone number. And any previous phone number or address, which is where the stale entries surface.

Working through the first several pages of each produces a list. Recording it with what each shows and whether it can be edited is the actual deliverable, since this recurs and the list makes the next check quick.

Claiming versus removing

Claiming is usually the better option and it is counterintuitive.

An unclaimed listing can be edited by others, reverts to aggregated data, and cannot be controlled. A claimed one is yours to correct and keep accurate.

Removal is genuinely available on some platforms and frequently is not. Where a directory will not remove an entry, claiming and correcting it is the achievable outcome.

The exception is a duplicate of an entry you already control, which should be merged or removed rather than maintained, since duplicates split whatever standing each has.

What to do about lead-selling platforms

A decision rather than a problem to fix.

Their listings will rank for your trade whether you participate or not, because that is their business model and they invest in it. You cannot remove yourself from the category.

The options are to pay and treat it as an advertising channel judged on cost per customer like any other, or to ignore it and compete on the searches where your own site and listing can win.

What is worth avoiding is paying without measuring, which is how these become a subscription nobody reviews. The relevant number is cost per customer acquired, and it is frequently worse than it appears because the same enquiry goes to several businesses.

The review question

A specific irritation worth addressing.

Some platforms display a rating assembled from reviews left elsewhere, or from a small number left directly, on a listing you never created. That rating appears in search results attached to your name.

Where the platform allows a response or a correction, claiming the listing is the route to it. Where it does not, the practical answer is the same as any unwanted result: build enough genuine presence that it sits below the things you control.

What not to do

The proportionate approach

Claim and correct the handful customers actually use. Fix a wrong phone number or a closed status wherever it appears. Note the rest and leave them.

Then check annually rather than continuously, since the aggregated data refreshes and errors reappear. An hour a year, working from the list you made the first time.

That is the same accuracy exercise as the citation work, and the two are genuinely the same task approached from different directions, as covered in local citations and what they are.

Frequently asked questions

Why is my business listed on sites I never registered with?

Directories compile entries from public records, aggregated business data, and each other. The details are whatever the source held when it was scraped.

Should I claim or remove an unwanted listing?

Claiming is usually better. An unclaimed listing can be edited by others and reverts to aggregated data, while a claimed one is yours to correct and keep accurate.

Which listings actually matter?

The map platforms, major review sites, and anything appearing when somebody searches your name. The long tail of low-traffic directories matters only where details are wrong.

What are lead-selling platforms doing?

Listing your business to look comprehensive while selling the enquiry to whoever pays. The listing is bait, and unless you pay it produces nothing for you.

What should I never do?

Pay to have a listing removed, which is a pattern rather than a service, and never ignore a wrong phone number, which has a direct cost wherever it appears.

How often should I check?

Annually, working from the list you made the first time. Aggregated data refreshes and errors reappear, so it recurs rather than being fixed once.

West Coast Media Solutions Inc. provides web design, web development, hosting, digital marketing, and business consulting to organisations across Canada, drawing on more than twenty-five years in the field.

Old details showing on sites you have never heard of?

We find what is actually out there, claim and correct what customers use, and leave you the list for next year.

Start a Conversation