Check what the visitors were looking for. If they wanted information you happen to have rather than the thing you sell, high traffic and no enquiries is the correct outcome, not a fault to fix.

The page that looks like a success

It is at the top of your analytics, it gets more visits than your homepage, and it has produced no work in two years.

The instinct is to fix its conversion: a stronger call to action, a form, a banner, something to convert all that attention.

Usually that fails, because the problem is not on the page.

Where the mismatch comes from

The visitors wanted something adjacent to what you sell rather than what you sell.

A plumber writes about how to stop a dripping tap. It ranks well, because a great many people search it, and every one of those people is looking to avoid hiring a plumber.

The page succeeds completely at the thing it was written to do. It just does that for an audience with no intention of becoming customers.

Traffic and enquiries are different quantities, and a page can be excellent at one while having no route to the other.

The three kinds of visitor

Most high-traffic, low-enquiry pages are full of the first group, because those searches are the most common ones in almost every field.

The second group is where useful content usually pays, and the third is served by service pages rather than by articles.

Working out which you have

The search terms bringing people to the page will tell you, and they are in your search console.

Terms beginning with how to, why does, what causes, and can I are mostly people intending to handle it themselves.

Terms including cost, near me, best, versus, and who are people considering paying somebody.

Read the actual list rather than assuming. A page you thought was attracting buyers is often attracting students, and occasionally the reverse is true and the page is worth much more attention than it has had.

A worked example

An electrical contractor's most visited page explained why a breaker trips repeatedly.

It received about forty times the traffic of any service page and had generated, as far as anybody could tell, two enquiries in three years.

The search terms were almost entirely diagnostic: people with a tripping breaker trying to understand it.

Rather than adding calls to action, they added one honest section near the end describing the three situations where this is not a job to continue investigating yourself, with a plain explanation of why.

Enquiries from the page went to roughly one a month. Not many, and they were unusually good ones, because anybody contacting them had read a page telling them when not to call.

The traffic did not change. What changed was that a small correct subset now had a reason to make contact.

What to do instead of forcing it

Three options, and choosing between them is the actual decision.

Leave it alone, and accept it as reputation rather than lead generation. A page many people find useful is doing something, and not everything has to convert.

Add a genuine bridge, as in the example: the specific point at which somebody in that situation should stop and get help, stated honestly rather than as a sales insertion.

Or use it to reach the pages that do convert, by linking from it to the service page a reader would want if they decided not to proceed alone.

What does not work is a banner asking a person who came to fix something themselves to book a consultation.

Judge pages by their job

Different pages exist for different reasons and holding them all to the same measure produces bad decisions.

A service page should be judged on enquiries, since that is what it is for.

A question page should be judged on whether it answers the question and whether it reduces the time you spend answering it by phone.

A reputation piece should be judged on whether informed readers who find it think better of you, which is nearly unmeasurable and still real.

Deciding a page's purpose before publishing, and writing it down, prevents the argument two years later about whether it is working.

The pages that should convert and do not

Worth separating clearly, because the advice above does not apply to them.

If a service page gets steady traffic from people searching for the thing you sell and produces no enquiries, that is a genuine fault and is usually one of a small number of things.

No obvious way to make contact, or a phone number in an image rather than a tappable link.

No price signal at all, so readers cannot tell whether you are plausible for them.

No evidence: no photographs of your own work, no reviews, nothing showing you have done this before.

Or a form that is broken, which is more common than anyone expects and worth testing before concluding anything else.

Write for the buying searches too

The underlying pattern is usually a site whose content is all one type.

Question and problem pages are easier and more enjoyable to write, so they accumulate, and the site ends up covering the diagnostic searches thoroughly and the buying searches not at all.

The correction is unglamorous: pages about what things cost, how to choose a supplier, what is included, and how the process works.

Those attract far less traffic and considerably more work, which is the reverse of the pattern most sites have.

The counter-case

Sometimes the high-traffic page is doing something you cannot measure and should be kept regardless.

Pages that other people link to are frequently of this type, and those links help everything else on the site rank, including the pages that do convert.

A page may also be read by somebody who does not act for a year and then remembers you, which no analytics will attribute.

The reasonable test is whether the page costs anything to keep. Almost always it does not, so leaving it alone is cheap. What is expensive is spending months writing more pages exactly like it while believing they are marketing.

The check

  1. Read the actual search terms bringing people to the page.
  2. Classify them: self-solving, deciding, or buying.
  3. State what the page is for, and judge it on that.
  4. Add an honest bridge if one genuinely exists.
  5. Link to the service page a reader might want next.
  6. Test the form before diagnosing anything else.
  7. Write something for the buying searches next.

Step seven is the one that changes the numbers, and it is the least appealing item on the list.

Pages people leave from are covered in the page everybody leaves from.

Frequently asked questions

Why does my most visited page produce no enquiries?

Usually because its visitors wanted information adjacent to what you sell rather than the thing itself. A page answering how to fix something attracts people avoiding hiring anybody.

How do I tell what visitors wanted?

Read the search terms in your search console. How to, why does, and what causes indicate self-solving. Cost, near me, best, and versus indicate somebody considering paying.

Should I add a call to action to fix it?

Not a generic one. Asking somebody who came to fix something themselves to book a consultation fails. An honest note about when to stop and get help works far better.

Is a page with no enquiries a failure?

Not necessarily. Decide a page's purpose before publishing and judge it on that. Reputation and reduced phone time are real outcomes that no conversion figure captures.

What if a service page gets traffic and no enquiries?

That is a genuine fault. Check for a broken form first, then for no visible contact route, no price signal, and no evidence of your own work.

What should I write instead?

Pages for buying searches: what things cost, how to choose a supplier, what is included, how the process works. Less traffic, considerably more work.

West Coast Media Solutions Inc. provides web design, web development, hosting, digital marketing, and business consulting to organisations across Canada, drawing on more than twenty-five years in the field.

Busiest page producing nothing?

Read the search terms behind it before changing anything. The page may be working exactly as it should.

Start a Conversation