A competitor above you is usually doing one identifiable thing better rather than something clever. Five things account for nearly all of it: a dedicated page where you have a section, more reviews, proximity to the searcher, genuinely deeper content, or a technical problem on your side. Checking which takes twenty minutes.

First, check which result you are losing

The map results and the organic results below them are separate competitions with different rules, and confusing them wastes a lot of effort.

If they are above you in the map pack, the factors are proximity to the searcher, review volume and recency, and profile completeness. Content barely enters into it and no amount of writing will move you.

If they are above you in the organic results, content, relevance, and links are what matter, and proximity is far weaker. This is the competition you can win from a desk.

Establishing which one you are actually losing determines everything that follows, and it is the step most often skipped.

The five things worth checking

They have a page and you have a paragraph

The most common answer by a wide margin. They rank for "gutter cleaning in Langley" because they have a page about gutter cleaning in Langley. You have gutter cleaning listed among eight services on one page. That is not a subtle difference and it is entirely fixable.

They have more reviews, or more recent ones

Particularly decisive in map results. Open both listings and compare the count and the date of the most recent. A competitor with steady recent reviews against your forty from three years ago is winning on the strongest local factor available.

They are simply closer

In map results, proximity to the person searching is a major factor and it is not something you can change. A business two blocks from the searcher will outrank one across town for many queries, regardless of quality. Recognising this saves months of effort chasing something structural.

Their page answers more of the question

Open both pages and compare honestly. Do they cover cost, timing, what the job involves, and what affects the price where you cover none of those? Depth here is not word count, it is how many of the reader's questions get resolved.

Something on your side is broken

Worth ruling out early because it is cheap to check and occasionally the whole answer. The page is not indexed, it is blocked, it loads slowly on mobile, or two of your own pages are competing for the same term.

What you can copy and what you cannot

Copy the structure. If their page answers six questions and yours answers two, that gap is the work, and it is legitimate to notice what a good page covers.

Do not copy the words. Beyond the obvious problem, duplicated text ranks worse than original text and it will not carry your evidence, your jobs, or your photographs, which is what would actually differentiate the page.

And do not copy their positioning if they are a fundamentally different kind of business. A national operator's page is written for a different set of constraints, and the local specificity you can bring is exactly what they cannot.

The check that takes twenty minutes

When they are genuinely bigger

Sometimes the honest answer is that a competitor has more resources, more links, and a longer history, and the broad term is not winnable in a reasonable timeframe.

That is not the end of it. The response is to compete where size matters less: more specific services, more specific places, and the questions their centrally produced content does not address. A national operator will outrank you on the general term and will not have a page about your particular neighbourhood, which is the approach set out in competing with a franchise as an independent.

Losing a term you were never going to win is not a failure. Spending a year on it instead of the fifteen terms you could win is.

Frequently asked questions

Why does a competitor rank above me?

Usually one identifiable thing: they have a dedicated page where you have a paragraph, they have more or more recent reviews, they are closer to the searcher, their page answers more questions, or something on your side is broken.

How do I know whether I am losing the map results or the organic results?

Search the term on a phone and look at where they appear relative to you. The two are separate competitions, and confusing them sends you after the wrong fix.

Can I outrank a competitor who is physically closer?

In the map results, often not, since proximity to the searcher is a major factor you cannot change. In the organic results below the map, proximity matters far less and content and relevance decide it.

Should I copy a competitor's page?

Copy the structure, meaning the questions their page answers that yours does not. Never copy the words, since duplicated text performs worse and carries none of your own evidence.

What is the most common reason for being outranked?

They have a dedicated page for the specific service and area while you have it listed among several services on one page. It is not subtle and it is entirely fixable.

What if the competitor is a much larger company?

Compete where size matters less: more specific services, more specific places, and the questions their centrally produced content cannot address. The broad term may not be winnable in a reasonable timeframe.

West Coast Media Solutions Inc. provides web design, web development, hosting, digital marketing, and business consulting to organisations across Canada, drawing on more than twenty-five years in the field.

Watching a competitor sit above you?

We will work out which of the five reasons applies to your situation and fix the one that is actually costing you the position.

Start a Conversation