A good domain is one someone can hear once, spell correctly, and type without hesitating. Everything else, including length, keywords, and extension, matters far less than that. The regrets are almost always about ambiguity: names that need spelling out on the phone, or that could plausibly be typed three different ways.
The test that matters
Say your proposed domain aloud to someone, once, without spelling it. Then ask them to type it.
If they get it right, it works. If they hesitate, ask you to repeat it, or produce a variation, that hesitation will happen thousands of times over the life of the business, and each occurrence is someone who did not reach you.
Trades businesses in particular give out their address verbally: on the phone, on a job, at the counter. A domain that survives being said aloud in a noisy room is worth more than a clever one.
What causes trouble
Ambiguous spellings
Words with common variants create permanent confusion. Anything where a listener must choose between spellings is a name that will be mistyped indefinitely.
Hyphens
Nobody says "hyphen" naturally, and a hyphenated name has to be spelled out every time. It also reads as the version somebody took when the better one was gone.
Numbers
Is it four or the digit? Both need explaining, and either way you own only half the traffic unless you buy both.
Doubled letters at word boundaries
Where one word ends with the letter the next begins with, the join is genuinely hard to hear and produces two plausible spellings.
Unintended readings
Run the whole string together and read it fresh. This is a well-documented category of error and it is entirely avoidable by asking two people to read it before purchase.
Names tied to something that will change
A single service, a single town, a current partner's name, or a year. Businesses expand and change, and a domain naming last year's business is a permanent constraint.
Keywords in the domain
The honest position: a keyword in the domain provides very little ranking benefit, and it has not provided much for a long time.
It does provide something else worth having, which is immediate clarity. Someone seeing a plumbing-related address in a search result knows what the business does before clicking, and that is a legitimate benefit even without any ranking effect.
The failure mode is the exact-match address stuffed with service and location, which reads as a landing page rather than a business and constrains you permanently to that service in that town.
Length
Shorter is better up to the point where it becomes ambiguous. A memorable and unambiguous fifteen-character domain beats a cryptic eight-character one.
Abbreviations that make sense internally rarely make sense to customers, and initials belong to whoever established them first.
Practical points before buying
- Check the business name is available too. Registering a domain does not entitle you to a business name, and using a name someone else has established as a trademark creates a problem regardless of who registered which domain first.
- Search the name. If an established business elsewhere uses it, you will compete with them in results for your own name permanently.
- Check the history. A previously registered domain may carry a history you do not want, which is covered separately in the risks of expired domains.
- Buy the obvious variants only where they are cheap and genuinely likely to be typed. Buying twelve defensive registrations for a small local business is money that would be better spent elsewhere.
- Register it in your own name. Non-negotiable, for the reasons in who owns your website.
The one that matters most
You will live with this decision far longer than you expect. Domains outlast websites, rebrands, and frequently the original owner's involvement in the business.
Spend an afternoon on it, say the candidates aloud to people who do not know your business, and choose the one nobody had to ask about twice.
Frequently asked questions
What makes a good domain name?
One that can be heard once, spelled correctly, and typed without hesitation. Length, keywords, and extension all matter considerably less than clarity, and most regrets involve names that require spelling out or could plausibly be typed several ways.
Should I use hyphens in a domain name?
Preferably not. Nobody says hyphen naturally when giving out an address verbally, so it must be spelled out every time, and hyphenated names tend to read as the version someone took when the better one was unavailable.
Do keywords in a domain name help SEO?
Very little, and they have not provided much benefit for a long time. They do provide immediate clarity to someone seeing the address in search results, which is a legitimate benefit, but an address stuffed with service and location terms reads as a landing page.
Should I buy multiple versions of my domain?
Only where variants are cheap and genuinely likely to be typed, such as an obvious alternative spelling. Registering a dozen defensive variations for a small local business is generally money better spent elsewhere.
How long should a domain name be?
Shorter is better only up to the point where it becomes ambiguous. A memorable, unambiguous fifteen-character name outperforms a cryptic eight-character one, and internal abbreviations rarely make sense to customers.
What should I check before registering a domain?
Whether the business name is available and not already established as someone else's trademark, whether an existing business elsewhere uses the name, whether the domain carries a previous history, and that the registration is in your own name.
West Coast Media Solutions Inc. builds websites for businesses across Canada and also operates a premium domain marketplace, which is a relevant interest to declare when reading anything below about buying domains. Registry policies change; verify current requirements before relying on them.
Thinking about a domain or a rebuild?
We build websites and have spent decades around domain names. Bring us the situation and we will tell you what it is worth and how to secure it.
Start a Conversation