Most good domains are registered and many are unused. Buying one is a negotiation where the seller's price depends heavily on how much they think you want it, which makes the approach itself the most important decision.

Find out what you are dealing with

Before contacting anybody, establish which situation you are in, because they behave differently.

A parked or unused domain. Registered and doing nothing, frequently held by an investor. A commercial transaction and the most likely to succeed.

An active business. Using it. Almost never for sale, and approaching costs you nothing but rarely produces anything.

An abandoned project. A site that stopped being updated years ago, held by somebody who may have forgotten it. Frequently the best opportunity, and the hardest to reach.

Listed for sale. Either on a marketplace or with a landing page inviting offers. The price is usually higher than the others and the process is simpler.

The public registration record shows the registrar and the expiry date, and privacy protection frequently hides the owner. The expiry date is worth noting, since a domain expiring soon may become available without a purchase.

The approach determines the price

The single most consequential decision, and most people get it wrong immediately.

The moment the owner knows a specific business wants the domain for a specific reason, the price reflects what they think it is worth to you rather than what it is worth generally.

Which means: do not lead with your company name, do not explain your plans, do not mention a launch date, and do not send it from an address at a domain that reveals who you are.

A short, unremarkable enquiry asking whether the domain is available and what they would consider is the version that produces a real number.

This is not deception. It is declining to disclose your negotiating position, which is ordinary.

Using a broker

Worth considering for a domain that genuinely matters.

A broker approaches on your behalf without revealing who you are, which solves the disclosure problem entirely. They also know current market levels, which is difficult to establish independently.

The cost is a commission, typically a percentage of the sale. For a modest domain that is not worth it; for one where the difference between a good and a bad negotiation is substantial, it frequently pays for itself.

Marketplaces that specialise in premium domains also serve this function, since listed prices give you a reference point for what comparable names sell for.

What domains actually sell for

Being realistic, since expectations are usually wrong in both directions.

Most unremarkable domains held by investors sell for modest amounts. Short, common-word, or exact-match commercial terms sell for considerably more, sometimes very considerably.

What raises the price: shortness, being a real word, a common extension, prior use, and any traffic it still receives.

What lowers it: hyphens, numbers, unusual extensions, misspellings, and length.

Before making an offer, look at what comparable names have sold for on public sales records, which is the only reasonable anchor available.

Making the offer

  1. Decide your maximum first, and hold to it.
  2. Open below it, since almost nobody accepts a first offer.
  3. Do not explain urgency, which is the most expensive thing you can reveal.
  4. Be prepared to walk, which is what gives the number credibility.
  5. Give it time, since sellers frequently return weeks later.

The last point is worth knowing. A refused offer is not a closed negotiation, and owners of unused domains reconsider when a renewal comes due.

Completing safely

The part where money is actually at risk.

Use an escrow service that specialises in domains. The buyer pays escrow, the domain is transferred, and the funds are released once the transfer completes. Neither party has to trust the other.

What to avoid entirely: paying directly to an individual before transfer, and any seller who insists on it. That is where the fraud in this market happens.

Confirm before paying that the domain can actually be transferred, meaning it is not within a lock period after registration or a recent transfer, and that the seller controls the account rather than being an intermediary.

Once transferred, verify it is in your account, in the business name, with the transfer lock re-enabled, which is the same settings checklist described in locking down the domain itself.

When to stop

A domain is worth what it saves you, not what you want it for.

Where the price exceeds what an alternative name plus the marketing to establish it would cost, the alternative is the better purchase.

Many successful businesses run on their second-choice domain, and none of their customers know or care.

Frequently asked questions

How do I know what situation I am in?

Check whether the domain is parked, actively used, an abandoned project, or listed for sale. The public registration record shows the registrar and expiry date.

Why does the approach matter so much?

Once the owner knows a specific business wants it for a specific reason, the price reflects what they think it is worth to you rather than its general value.

What should the first message avoid?

Your company name, your plans, any launch date, and an email address at a domain that identifies you. A short unremarkable enquiry produces a real number.

Is a broker worth it?

For a domain that genuinely matters, frequently. They approach without revealing who you are and know current market levels, in exchange for a commission.

How do I complete safely?

Use a domain escrow service. Never pay an individual directly before transfer, and confirm the domain is not within a lock period and that the seller controls the account.

When should I stop?

When the price exceeds what an alternative name plus the marketing to establish it would cost. Many successful businesses run on their second choice.

West Coast Media Solutions Inc. provides web design, web development, hosting, digital marketing, and business consulting to organisations across Canada, drawing on more than twenty-five years in the field.

Name you want is registered and doing nothing?

We approach without revealing who is asking, which is usually the difference between a real number and one based on how much you want it.

Start a Conversation